rgbaccounting · Blog

Taxes & CRA Planning

U.S. Brokerage Account: I Never Withdrew the Money… So Why Would I Owe Tax?

By Roberto Belingueres · 2026-09-09T00:27:47+00:00

U.S. Brokerage Account: I Never Withdrew the Money… So Why Would I Owe Tax?

Understanding realized and unrealized gains on foreign investment accounts

Table of Contents

Understanding realized and unrealized gains on foreign investment accounts

By Roberto Belingueres, Founder & CEO, RGB Accounting | 7-minute read

The Difference Between Market Growth and Taxable Gains

As more Canadians invest internationally through foreign brokerage and wealth-management firms, one question keeps coming up: “I did not withdraw any money, so why would I owe tax?” The answer depends on whether the investments merely increased in value or whether you actually sold securities inside the account.

Suppose you purchase investments for USD $100,000 and they are worth USD $140,000 at year-end. If nothing has been sold, the USD $40,000 increase is generally an unrealized gain. In most cases, this market appreciation is not taxable in Canada at that time because no disposition has occurred.

Scenario 1: Unrealized gain

Now suppose the portfolio manager sells those securities and immediately reinvests the proceeds. You may never receive cash in your personal bank account, but a sale has still occurred. For Canadian tax purposes, that sale will generally be a disposition that can create a capital gain or capital loss.

Key point: Canadian tax generally focuses on whether an investment was sold—not whether the proceeds were withdrawn from the account.

Scenario 2: Realized gain

Many investors use discretionary portfolio-management services. In these arrangements, an advisor may buy and sell securities without obtaining the investor’s approval for every individual trade. The proceeds can remain entirely inside the account and be reinvested automatically.

Annual statements may therefore contain all of the following:

What Happens in Managed Investment Accounts?

Only the appropriate taxable amounts should be reported on the Canadian return. The portfolio’s total increase in value is not automatically the capital gain to report.

A frequent misconception is that no tax arises because the proceeds were reinvested. Reinvestment is a separate transaction. Once you sell securities, you generally realize the gain or loss. Buying replacement securities does not reverse that sale or defer the Canadian tax consequences unless a specific rollover provision applies.

Why Reinvestment Does Not Erase a Disposition

The first sale may still produce a $15,000 capital gain before transaction costs and Canadian-dollar conversion adjustments.

Foreign brokerage statements can be complex. A year-end portfolio summary alone may not be sufficient. Depending on the institution and country, the supporting package may include:

Documents Needed for Accurate Reporting

These records help distinguish realized gains from unrealized appreciation, identify dividends and interest, determine foreign tax credits, and support the adjusted cost base used for Canadian reporting.

Form T1135 is an information return used to disclose certain specified foreign property when the applicable cost threshold is exceeded. It does not replace the requirement to report taxable income on the Canadian income tax return.

T1135 Versus the Canadian Income Tax Return

Depending on the facts, the taxpayer may still need to report:

A T1135 can therefore be technically complete while the T1 remains incomplete—or the reverse. Both filings must be reconciled to the same underlying investment records.

Back to Blog

Built with WebCore